|
Rangefinder
Magazine
October 2003
First Exposure: by Peter Kotsinadelis
Microtek’s ScanMaker 6800
Microtek is a leading manufacturer
of imaging products that range from flatbed and film scanners to
monitors, digital cameras and projectors. For over 20 years they
have produced a wide range of image scanners and currently have more
than a dozen models on the market. Their most recent flatbed, the
ScanMaker 6800, is the first flatbed scanner to incorporate Applied
Science Fiction’s Digital ICE dust and defect removal software
for photo prints. It also offers an optical resolution of 4800 x
2400 dpi resolution, 48-bit color depth, includes both FireWire and
Hi-Speed USB (USB 2.0) interfaces, and has an integrated 4 x 5 transparency
adapter. With all this and a street price under $400, could this
be the scanner you have been looking for?
Features: Although the ScanMaker
6800 provides an optical resolution of 4800 x 2400dpi, the software
that accompanies the scanner provides
interpolated resolution up to 65,535dpi when connected to a PC or 32,767dpi
to a Mac. The unit includes an AC adapter and power cable, USB 2.0
cable, and CDs that provide Microtek ScanMaker and Adobe PhotoShop
Elements
software. Microtek includes a FireWire card with installation guide
for PC users that want to add a FireWire connection, while Mac G3/G4
or iMac
DV users running OS 9.x can make use of their built-in FireWire or
USB ports.
|
|
Only when scanning prints will a check box appear
on the bottom of the settings screen, allowing you to enable Digital
ICE. |
This is how the Microtek’s
ScanWizard software with Advanced Control appears when scanning
an image, in this case a slide. |
The ScanMaker 6800 offers several
built-in features accessed by buttons on the scanner’s front panel. These features
integrate with Microtek’s
ScanWizard 5.0 software to provide the ability to copy, scan, and
e-mail documents. There is also an OCR (Optical Character Recognition)
capability
that can transform typed documents into files for use with word processing
and other applications. Additionally, for those looking to connect
the scanner to a local area network (LAN), Microtek includes their
own LAN
Wizard network scanning software to simplify installation.
 |
 |
| This particular scan was accomplished
using an Epson 2450. |
 |
The lid
on the ScanMaker 6800 provides a built-in light plate for transparencies
and negatives and has a short cable on the rear of
the lid that must
connect to the scanner’s accessory port to operate. On the
top of the lid is an area that Microtek refers to as “FilmView,” basically
a built-in light source that allows you to view and select images
from your filmstrips or transparencies prior to scanning. Before
using the
ScanMaker 6800, you need to unlock the scanner using the safety
lock switch located on the left side. The power switch is located
on the
rear of the scanner.
 |
 |
A crop of the Big Ben image, showing a side by side
comparison of how well the Microtek
rendered the face of Big Ben versus the comparable Epson 2450. Even
though they were from the identical slide and using the same optical
resolution, detail and contrast varied. |
 |
The ScanMaker 6800’s main feature is
the integrated Digital ICE software that provides the ability
to remove defects and dust from photo
prints. You can scan an image up to 8.5 x 11.7 inches (216 x
297mm) and the software will then create a defect map that identifies
the locations
of the defects and subsequently removes them. Although this process
does add time to the scanning process, it is simple, automatic,
and far better
than other software that has a tendency to soften the image.
Once installed, the user can operate the ScanWizard
5.0 software independently or through an application such as Photoshop.
Once
ScanWizard is up
and running you have the option of using either the standard
or advanced control panel. The standard panel simplifies selections
required
for scanning by providing buttons on the screen that group
the features into
nine segments.
They are:
Preview–PreScans and previews the images.
Scan To—Destination for final image such as printer, email, etc.
Original—Photo, Text Document, Film, etc.
Scan Type—True color, Web color, Gray, or Black and White.
Purpose—Output presets for OnScreen Viewing, printing, etc.
Scale Output—Output size or ratio.
Adjust—Brightness, Contrast, Sharpness, or Saturation.
Reset—Revert to default settings.
Preferences—Customize scanning functions/appearance of standard
panel.
Note: There is also a zoom-in scale that allows
you to vary the size of the preview image.
When using the Advanced Panel, the user has direct access to
all features found within the standard panel with additional
selections
such as
the ability to enable/disable Digital ICE for Photo Prints,
Advanced Image
Correction tools that allow adjustments to the tone curve,
brightness and contrast settings, color corrections, and
a descreening setting
when scanning images from periodicals.
|
|
|
Side-by-side “unadjusted” scans
of a 35mm negative from both the Microtek 6800 and Epson 2450 scanners.
L - Microtek 6800 print scan R - Epson 2450 print scan |
A color negative film scan comparison
of the left eye from above scan. L - Microtek 6800 R - Epson 2450 |
The same scan without and then with Digital ICE enabled.
In the bottom image with Digital ICE enabled, the spot near the center
of
the eyebrow was detected and removed. |
There is also an Advanced
information window that indicates zoom level, mouse cursor position,
color meter (values or
percentages) and output
options, and a displayed sample area. A color tab provides
access
to brightness, contrast, and gamma settings and displays
histogram and
curves. Settings can be saved and reloaded for later use.
So
Just How Good Is It?
Microtek’s ScanMaker 6800 was simple to install and get up and
running. For testing purposes the scanner was connected
through a Hi-Speed USB 2.0 connection on a PC. I found the ScanWizard
5.0 software easy
to use and operate and had no problem using it standalone
or through Photoshop. The scanner was designed for both print and film
negative/transparency
scanning, but it was disappointing to find that Digital
ICE only worked when scanning prints. When scanning film, the Digital
ICE enable selection
does not appear, leaving the user without an automated
means for defect and/or dust removal from negative or transparencies
scans.
Although the ScanMaker 6800 had a hi-speed USB
2.0 connection, overall scanning speed of the ScanMaker 68000 was slower
than comparable scanners that used the same USB 2.0
port.
Scanning
prints with
Digital
ICE enabled
added to the scanning time but did produce some good
results. Scans were made with and without Digital ICE
enabled, and
although the
defect as
seen in the top image on page 84 above the eyebrow
was removed, smaller dust markings remained.
To see how this scanner
compared to an Epson 2450, several more tests scans of film and transparencies
were made.
While the Epson
2450
has film and transparency holders, Microtek’s
ScanMaker 6800 uses a flexible plastic mask that
you place on the flatbed glass that shows
a 4 x 5 inch area where you can place film or transparencies
directly onto the glass. While this method did work
fairly well, I found the ScanMaker
6800 color reproduction not as accurate as that of
the Epson 2450 when scanning transparencies (see
the Big Ben negatives, page 84) or the negatives
of the blond in the red jacket, also on page 84.
Next, we wanted to see how well the ScanMaker
6800 captured detail. Several scans were made from transparencies
and
negatives at
2400dpi, the maximum
optical resolution for both the ScanMaker 6800
and the Epson 2450. Each image was then cropped to show
only
a small portion
of the
original, and placed side by side. In both images
the scans produced by the
Microtek ScanMaker 6800 showed less detail than
those from the Epson 2450.
The ScanMaker 6800 is the only scanner on
the market to have integrated Digital ICE, a feature that
will benefit many
looking for the ability
to restore and enhance scans made from photographic
prints. With its automated process for defect
and dust removal,
this scanner
can provide
the user with considerable timesavings. If I
were allowed just one wish to improve the ScanMaker
6800 it would
be
to enable
Digital ICE when
scanning negatives and transparencies.
Peter Kotsinadelis
is a freelance writer/photographer living in
Pleasanton, California.
A frequent
contributor to photography related publications
he may be reached at peterk727@yahoo.com.
|